State of Illinois
92nd General Assembly
Legislation

   [ Search ]   [ PDF text ]   [ Legislation ]   
[ Home ]   [ Back ]   [ Bottom ]


[ Introduced ][ Engrossed ][ Enrolled ]
[ House Amendment 001 ][ House Amendment 004 ][ House Amendment 005 ]
[ Senate Amendment 001 ]


92_SB2155gms

 
                            State of Illinois
                         OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
                      Springfield, Illinois  62706
      George H. Ryan
      GOVERNOR
                                                    August 23, 2002
      To the Honorable Members of
        The Illinois Senate
      92nd General Assembly
          Pursuant to the  authority  vested  in  the  Governor  by
      Article  IV,  Section  9(e)  of  the Illinois Constitution of
      1970, and re-affirmed by the People of the State of  Illinois
      by popular referendum in 1974, and conforming to the standard
      articulated  by  the Illinois Supreme Court in People ex rel.
      Klinger  v.  Howlett,  50  Ill.2d  242  (1972),   Continental
      Illinois  National Bank and Trust Co. v. Zagel, 78 Ill.2d 387
      (1979), people ex rel. City of Canton v.  Crouch,  79  Ill.2d
      356  (1980),  and  County  of Kane v. Carlson, 116 Ill.2d 186
      (1987), that gubernatorial  action  be  consistent  with  the
      fundamental  purposes  and  the  intent of the bill, I hereby
      return Senate Bill 2155 entitled "AN ACT in relation to civil
      liabilities," with my specific recommendations for change.
          Senate Bill  2155  provides  the  owner  or  operator  of
      off-road  riding  facilities  not  only  civil  immunity, but
      criminal immunity as well, from legal suits  brought  on  the
      basis  of  noise  or  sound  emissions.   Senate   Bill  2155
      provides  these immunities to (i) the facilities in existence
      on January 1, 2002, and  (ii)  the  facilities  in  operation
      after  January  1,  2002,  that  meet at least one additional
      location, zoning, or operation requirement.  Senate Bill 2155
      also provides that  the  civil  immunity  for  facilities  in
      existence  after  January 1, 2002, does not extend to willful
      and wanton misconduct outside the normal use of the facility.
          Although existing off-road riding  facilities  may  merit
      some protections against nuisance suits of persons who choose
      to  locate  next  to  one of these current facilities, Senate
      Bill  2155  proposes  to  extend  these  protections  to  the
      opposite scenario where new facilities  may  seek  to  locate
      near   residential   areas.     Senate  Bill  2155  also  may
      inadvertently   affect   pending   suits   concerning   these
      facilities.  Therefore,  my  amendatory  changes  delete  the
      protections  for  facilities that open after January 1, 2002,
      and provide that  the  immunity  protections  only  apply  to
      causes  of  action accruing on or after the effective date of
      this bill.
          In addition, Senate Bill  2155  indeterminately  provides
      criminal immunity to these facilities that the State does not
      regulate  for  noise pollution and waives civil immunity only
      for willful and wanton misconduct "outside" the normal use of
      an existing facility.  Thus, the  amendatory  changes  delete
      the  criminal  immunity provisions and waive immunity for any
      willful and wanton misconduct occurring in the  operation  of
      the facility.
          For  these reasons, I hereby return Senate Bill 2155 with
      the following recommendations for change:
          on page 1, by replacing lines  21  through  27  with  the
           following:
               "(b)   An  owner  or  operator of an off-road riding
           facility in existence on January 1, 2002 is not  subject
           to any action for public or private nuisance or trespass
           arising  out  of  or  as a consequence of noise or sound
           emissions resulting from the normal use of the  off-road
           riding  facility.   Further,  no court in this State may
           enjoin"; and
          on page 1, line 28, by replacing "a" with "an"; and
          on page 1, by replacing line 31 with the following:
               "(c)  The immunity in this Section does not apply if
           there is willful or wanton misconduct in  the  operation
           of  the  off-road riding facility.  This Section applies
           only to causes  of  action  accruing  on  or  after  the
           effective  date  of  this  amendatory  Act  of  the 92nd
           General Assembly."; and
          On page 2, by deleting lines 1 through 23.
 
          With  these  changes,  Senate  Bill  2155  will  have  my
      approval.  I respectfully request your concurrence.
                                             Sincerely,
                                             George H. Ryan
                                             GOVERNOR

[ Top ]