Rep. Michael J. Madigan

Filed: 5/2/2013

 

 


 

 


 
09800SB0001ham003LRB098 05457 EFG 45378 a

1
AMENDMENT TO SENATE BILL 1

2    AMENDMENT NO. ______. Amend Senate Bill 1, AS AMENDED, with
3reference to page and line numbers of House Amendment No. 1, by
4replacing line 4 on page 1 through line 9 on page 9 with the
5following:
 
6    "Section 1. Statement and Findings.
7    At the time of passage of this amendatory Act of the 98th
8General Assembly, Illinois possesses a lower credit rating than
9each of the other 49 states. This is a consequence both of
10atypically large debts and of structural imbalances that will,
11unless addressed by the General Assembly, lead to rapidly
12growing debts. The debts include a backlog of bills exceeding
13one-fourth of the State's annual general revenue, and
14approximately $100 billion in unfunded pension liabilities.
15The structural imbalances result from projected growth in
16non-discretionary and formula-driven expenses that
17significantly outpace projected revenue growth. Of the factors

 

 

09800SB0001ham003- 2 -LRB098 05457 EFG 45378 a

1that drive this phenomenon, the most substantial by far is the
2rapid growth of the annual pension payment, which increased by
3nearly $1 billion between Fiscal Year 2012 and Fiscal Year
42013, and will again increase by nearly $1 billion between
5Fiscal Year 2013 and Fiscal Year 2014, at which time it will
6consume approximately one-fifth of anticipated general
7revenue.
8    The State has taken significant action to ameliorate the
9State's fiscal troubles. In 2011, the State increased the
10income tax in Public Act 96-1496. Recognizing that increased
11revenue alone would not solve the problem, the State has
12enacted a series of budgets that included deep cuts to
13discretionary programs, including programs that are essential
14in order to provide for the health, safety, welfare, and
15educational development of the people of Illinois.
16    The State has both reduced the size of its workforce and
17reduced discretionary spending. The staffing level is now the
18lowest it has been in at least the last 25 years. Discretionary
19spending from the General Revenue Fund (GRF) has been reduced
20by over $2.8 billion since Fiscal Year 2009, including
21significant reductions for primary and secondary education,
22higher education, public safety, and human services, including
23health care for the poor.
24    In 2010, Public Act 96-889 established a package of pension
25benefits for new employees that has been determined to be among
26the least expensive public employee retirement schemes in the

 

 

09800SB0001ham003- 3 -LRB098 05457 EFG 45378 a

1country. It can be argued that the new package of pension
2benefits has placed government employers at a competitive
3disadvantage, and our public universities, which are vital
4educational and economic institutions, have been exposed to a
5significant risk.
6    In the spring of 2012, the General Assembly made
7significant reductions to the Medicaid program in Public Acts
897-687, 97-688, 97-689, 97-690, and 97-691, a series of reforms
9to the Medicaid program that is projected to reduce State debt
10by decreasing services, increasing the rate of taxation of
11tobacco purchases, and accessing available federal funds. The
12reductions include the elimination of a prescription drug
13program for low to middle income seniors, provider rate cuts,
14elimination of health care for adults whose families make above
15133% of the federal poverty limit ($31,322 for a family of
16four), elimination of restorative dental treatments for adults
17covered by Medicaid, and utilization limits on all remaining
18services covered by Medicaid. While the Medicaid reforms will
19result in savings for the State, these reforms have resulted in
20the denial of crucial health care to hundreds of thousands of
21needy citizens, threatening to further destabilize an
22already-troubled safety net.
23    The General Assembly took significant steps to reduce the
24cost of current and retired employee health care costs. With
25Public Act 97-695, the General Assembly eliminated provisions
26that require that retired state employees with more than 20

 

 

09800SB0001ham003- 4 -LRB098 05457 EFG 45378 a

1years of service receive a 100% premium subsidy for retiree
2health care coverage after 20 years of service. Beginning with
3Fiscal Year 2014, State employees will be required to
4contribute significantly more toward healthcare premiums,
5copays, and deductibles. However, the backlog of payments to
6providers is estimated to be nearly $1.8 billion at the end of
7Fiscal Year 2013, and providers will continue to experience a
8delayed payment cycle.
9    Notwithstanding these and many other steps and their major
10fiscal, economic, and human impact, the fiscal situation in
11Illinois continues to deteriorate. Cuts as well as the
12inability to pay bills due and owing have had a significant
13impact on each branch of government, units of local government,
14social service providers, and other vendors.
15    Two-thirds of Illinois school districts are deficit
16spending, even after layoffs and programmatic reductions. For
17Fiscal Year 2013, General State Aid payments to school
18districts are currently being prorated at 89% of the calculated
19amount. For Fiscal Year 2014, the Governor's introduced level
20of General State Aid payments would result in a proration of
2182%.
22    Cuts to the budget of the Department of Corrections have
23resulted in the closing of two major prisons and three Adult
24Transitional Centers. Similarly, the Department of Juvenile
25Justice was forced to close two youth centers. Funding for
26probation services to help break the cycle of recidivism and

 

 

09800SB0001ham003- 5 -LRB098 05457 EFG 45378 a

1improve public safety has steadily declined over the past 5
2years due to the fiscal strain on the state budget.
3    Consequently, the coming months and years will necessarily
4see much more action by the State to achieve fiscal
5stabilization. If these steps toward fiscal stabilization do
6not include pension reform to restrain the growth of the annual
7pension payment, the result will be devastating and dramatic
8cuts to education, public safety, human services, and
9transportation. The impact of such actions on the Illinois
10economy, and on the health, safety, welfare, and educational
11development of the people, would likely be extremely severe.
12This harm could include significant economic contraction,
13which would in turn exacerbate the underlying fiscal challenge.
14    The General Assembly has held numerous hearings and
15reviewed hundreds of documents detailing the State's pension
16liability problem, probable solutions, and constitutional
17issues with proposed reform. Given that and all of the above:
18    The General Assembly finds that the fiscal crisis in the
19State of Illinois jeopardizes the health, safety, and welfare
20of the people and compromises the ability to maintain a
21representative and orderly government.
22    The General Assembly finds that the pension liability is so
23great, and the State's fiscal condition is so challenged, that
24it is doubtful whether any set of actions by the State that do
25not include substantial reforms to its pension systems can
26result in the full payment of all promised benefits.

 

 

09800SB0001ham003- 6 -LRB098 05457 EFG 45378 a

1    The General Assembly finds that in order to truly solve the
2State's pension problem, a reform measure must render the
3pension liability affordable on an actuarially sound funding
4schedule, and it must commit the State to maintaining this
5schedule.
6    The General Assembly finds that the reforms in this
7amendatory Act of the 98th General Assembly are necessary to
8address the fiscal crisis without incurring further severe and
9irreparable harm to the public welfare.
10    The General Assembly finds that this amendatory Act of the
1198th General Assembly constitutes the substantial reform of the
12State's pension systems that, along with a series of further
13steps toward fiscal stabilization, will enable the State to
14credibly promise the full and timely payment of all pension
15benefits without incurring unacceptable harm to other areas of
16State interest.
17    The General Assembly finds that this amendatory Act of the
1898th General Assembly, with its significant cost-savings, its
19institution of an actuarially accepted payment schedule, and
20its historic funding commitment, is reasonable and necessary in
21order to meet these goals and solve the State's pension
22problem."; and
 
23by replacing line 23 on page 10 through line 8 on page 11 with
24the following:
25"Notwithstanding any other provision of this Act, employers

 

 

09800SB0001ham003- 7 -LRB098 05457 EFG 45378 a

1shall not be required to bargain over matters affected by the
2changes, the impact of changes, and the implementation of
3changes made to Article 14, 15, or 16 of the Illinois Pension
4Code, or to Article 1 of that Code as it applies to those
5Articles, by this amendatory Act of the 98th General Assembly
6or over any other provision of Article 14, 15 or 16 of the
7Illinois Pension Code, or of Article 1 of that Code as it
8applies to those Articles, which are prohibited subjects of
9bargaining; nor shall the changes, the impact of changes, or
10the implementation of changes made to Article 14, 15, or 16 of
11the Illinois Pension Code, or to Article 1 of that Code as it
12applies to those Articles, by this amendatory Act of the 98th
13General Assembly or any other provision of Article 14, 15 or 16
14of the Illinois Pension Code, or of Article 1 of that Code as
15it applies to those Articles, be subject to interest
16arbitration or any award issued pursuant to interest
17arbitration. The provisions of this Section shall not apply to
18an employment contract or collective bargaining agreement that
19is in effect on the effective date of this amendatory Act of
20the 98th General Assembly and has not been amended, renewed, or
21terminated after that date."; and
 
22on page 11, in line 11, by replacing "Act" with "Section"; and
 
23on page 18, by replacing lines 18 through 21 with the
24following:

 

 

09800SB0001ham003- 8 -LRB098 05457 EFG 45378 a

1"first."; and
 
2on page 48, in line 12, by replacing "includes" with "include";
3and
 
4on page 48, by replacing lines 21 through 26 with the
5following:
6"make the payments and transfers required to be made by the
7State pursuant to subsections (c) and (d). The State further
8pledges that the State"; and
 
9on page 49, in line 3, immediately after "Board", by inserting
10"under this Section"; and
 
11on page 92, in line 25, by replacing "amended or renewed" with
12"amended, renewed, or terminated"; and
 
13on page 144, in line 11, by replacing "includes" with
14"include"; and
 
15on page 144, by replacing lines 20 through 25 with the
16following:
17"make the payments and transfers required to be made by the
18State pursuant to subsections (c) and (d). The State further
19pledges that the State"; and
 

 

 

09800SB0001ham003- 9 -LRB098 05457 EFG 45378 a

1on page 145, in line 2, immediately after "Board", by inserting
2"under this Section"; and
 
3on page 162, in line 15, by replacing "amended or renewed" with
4"amended, renewed, or terminated"; and
 
5on page 171, by replacing lines 5 and 6 with the following:
6"of this phrase is a clarification of existing law."; and
 
7on page 201, in line 19, by replacing "includes" with
8"include"; and
 
9on page 202, by replacing lines 2 through 7 with the following:
10"make the payments and transfers required to be made by the
11State pursuant to subsections (c) and (d). The State further
12pledges that the State"; and
 
13on page 202, in line 10, immediately after "Board", by
14inserting "under this Section"; and
 
15on page 217, in line 24, by replacing "amended or renewed" with
16"amended, renewed, or terminated"; and
 
17on page 262, in line 15, by replacing "includes" with
18"include"; and
 

 

 

09800SB0001ham003- 10 -LRB098 05457 EFG 45378 a

1by replacing line 24 on page 262 through line 3 on page 263
2with the following:
3"make the payments and transfers required to be made by the
4State pursuant to subsections (c) and (d). The State further
5pledges that the State"; and
 
6on page 263, in line 6, immediately after "Board", by inserting
7"under this Section"; and
 
8on page 276, by replacing lines 1 through 11 with the
9following:
10"Notwithstanding any other provision of this Act, employers
11shall not be required to bargain over matters affected by the
12changes, the impact of changes, and the implementation of
13changes made to Article 14, 15, or 16 of the Illinois Pension
14Code, or to Article 1 of that Code as it applies to those
15Articles, by this amendatory Act of the 98th General Assembly
16or over any other provision of Article 14, 15 or 16 of the
17Illinois Pension Code, or of Article 1 of that Code as it
18applies to those Articles, which are prohibited subjects of
19bargaining; nor shall the changes, the impact of changes, or
20the implementation of changes made to Article 14, 15, or 16 of
21the Illinois Pension Code, or to Article 1 of that Code as it
22applies to those Articles, by this amendatory Act of the 98th
23General Assembly or any other provision of Article 14, 15 or 16
24of the Illinois Pension Code, or of Article 1 of that Code as

 

 

09800SB0001ham003- 11 -LRB098 05457 EFG 45378 a

1it applies to those Articles, be subject to interest
2arbitration or any award issued pursuant to interest
3arbitration. The provisions of this Section shall not apply to
4an employment contract or collective bargaining agreement that
5is in effect on the effective date of this amendatory Act of
6the 98th General Assembly and has not been amended, renewed, or
7terminated after that date."; and
 
8on page 276, in line 14, by replacing "Act" with "Section"; and
 
9on page 277, by replacing lines 8 through 11 with the
10following:
 
11    "Section 97. Severability and inseverability. The
12provisions of this Act are severable, except that the changes
13made to subsections (a), (a-1), (a-2), and (a-3) of Section
142-119.1, to subsections (d), (d-1), (d-2), and (d-3) of Section
1515-136, to subsections (a) and (b-3) of Section 16-158, and to
16Sections 2-124, 2-125, 14-114, 14-131, 14-132, 15-155, 15-156,
1716-133.1, and 16-158.2 of the Illinois Pension Code are
18mutually dependent and inseverable.".